Pitched Unfairly

BarbieA new product pitch by Ruth Handler

A doll who gets to be a grown-up.

Mattel leadership · Hawthorne, 1958

Outfits sold separately. That's the business.

The customer insight

Girls don't play mother. They play grown-up.

Barbara and her friends give their paper dolls jobs, dates and weddings. Nobody plays the baby.

Paper doll wardrobe Cut on the dotted line

  • Goes to the office
  • Has a date
  • Gets married
  • Flies to Paris
Field notes: Barbara and friends, our living room

Who it's for

Three people decide. Only one of them plays.

The buyer
MomPays $3. Says yes when her daughter asks for it by name.
The gatekeeper
The store’s toy buyerUsually a man. Has not, to his knowledge, played with paper dolls.

The player

The girl who's done with baby dolls

She chooses the doll, names the outfit she wants next, and asks for it every week.

Size: grown-up, someday

Evidence the behavior exists

Girls already buy the wardrobe. They just cut it out.

Behavior
Plays grown-up roles
Collects a wardrobe
Stands up in her hands
Made for American girls

Every box checked. Only one signature missing, and it is in this room.

Switzerland · 1956

Sales slip

  • 1Lilli doll, for BarbaraUser testing
  • 1Lilli doll, for MattelReference
  • 1Lilli doll, for MattelBackup reference

Total dolls3

Expense report pending

Field research

Europe already sells her. I bought three.

Lilli has sold in West Germany since 1955. Children dress her in outfits sold separately.

The product

One doll for $3. Twenty-two outfits, sold separately.

22 outfits, $1 to $5 each
Height
11.5 inches
Price
$3
Hair
Blonde or brunette
Made in
Japan, hand-finished
Name
Barbie, after Barbara

The objection, and the answer

Mothers won't buy her? Daughters will ask.

You said Mothers will never buy their daughters a doll with a grown-up figure.

They'll ask for her by name.

We talk to daughters directly, every week, on television.

How we reach customers

Toy makers advertise at Christmas. We advertise every week.

The toy industry

Mattel, since 1955

$500,000

52 weeks of the Mickey Mouse Club, signed in 1955. About what the whole company was worth.

Leadership was nervous then, too.

The economics

The doll is the razor. The wardrobe is the blade.

Average outfit price

Doll $3Wardrobe $18Total $21

The ask

Approve the run. Launch at Toy Fair, March 9, 1959.

  • 1production runMade in Japan, finished by hand
  • 22outfitsDesigned by Charlotte Johnson
  • $3priceOutfits from $1 to $5

ForecastBuyers: lukewarm.Girls: not.