New Coke and the Pepsi Challenge

200,000 sips said change it. The can disagreed. Competitive and market analysis, 1985, rebuilt as a live deck you can play and steal. More in Templates, strategy and planning.

Coca-Cola deck, first slide Play the deck
  • 10 slides
  • ~200,000 taste tests
  • Lead down to 2.9 pts
  • 79 days

Steal the competitive and market analysis structure

10 slides, one job each, in this order. Swap in your story and keep the order.

  1. 01
    CoverThe finding and the matchup in one line: who is winning what.
  2. 02
    The questionThe one question this analysis answers, and the decision riding on it.
  3. 03
    The marketShare over time for you and the main rival, with the gap you are trying to explain.
  4. 04
    Who competes, on whatA grid of the dimensions that matter, with the one row you lose highlighted.
  5. 05
    What customers valueWhat buyers say they want, and exactly how you measured it: sample, cost, format.
  6. 06
    SWOTStrengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats, plus a box for what customers feel, so it leads to a move.
  7. 07
    What the data can't tell usThe limits of the method: what it measured versus how people actually buy and use.
  8. 08
    ImplicationsThree things that must now be true, and the stake if you act on them.
  9. 09
    Recommendation and testThe move, the date, and the signals with baselines that would prove you wrong.
  10. 10
    What we'd check againThe lesson to carry into the next analysis, stated as a rule.
What good strategy and planning do, and where they fail
  • Score last year before planning the next.
  • Name the few bets and, just as clearly, what you will stop doing.
  • Targets with owners and dates; resources follow the bets.
  • A list of everything
  • Bets without owners
  • Nothing stopped

The deck, slide by slide

Each one opens the live deck at that slide.

  1. Coca-Cola deck, slide 1: Pepsi is winning the sip. We can win it back. 01Pepsi is winning the sip. We can win it back.
  2. Coca-Cola deck, slide 2: We outspend Pepsi by $100 million. Why are we losing? 02We outspend Pepsi by $100 million. Why are we losing?
  3. Coca-Cola deck, slide 3: Our lead fell from 6.8 points to 2.9 in nine years. 03Our lead fell from 6.8 points to 2.9 in nine years.
  4. Coca-Cola deck, slide 4: We win every lever we pay for. We lose the sip. 04We win every lever we pay for. We lose the sip.
  5. Coca-Cola deck, slide 5: Customers told us what they want: a sweeter sip. 05Customers told us what they want: a sweeter sip.
  6. Coca-Cola deck, slide 6: The SWOT says change the formula. One box is empty. 06The SWOT says change the formula. One box is empty.
  7. Coca-Cola deck, slide 7: We tested a sip. People drink a can. 07We tested a sip. People drink a can.
  8. Coca-Cola deck, slide 8: If the sip decides, the formula is the lever. 08If the sip decides, the formula is the lever.
  9. Coca-Cola deck, slide 9: Launch the new taste April 23, 1985. The hotline is our test. 09Launch the new taste April 23, 1985. The hotline is our test.
  10. Coca-Cola deck, slide 10: Test the whole can. Then ask what losing it would feel like. 10Test the whole can. Then ask what losing it would feel like.
What really happened, and what the 2026 rebuild changes

What really happened, 1985

  1. Coke outsells Pepsi better than 2 to 1 in the mid-1950s
  2. The Pepsi Challenge puts blind taste tests on TV from 1975
  3. Coke's lead falls from 6.8 points (1975) to 2.9 (1984); Pepsi leads in grocery
  4. Coke outspends Pepsi by $100 million and still loses share
  5. Project Kansas: about 200,000 consumers, $4 million, two years of taste tests
  6. A sweeter formula wins 55% of 191,000 tasters over Pepsi and the original
  7. April 23, 1985: New Coke replaces the 99-year-old formula
  8. The hotline jumps from 400 calls a day to 1,500; the Old Cola Drinkers of America forms
  9. July 11, 1985: Coca-Cola Classic returns, 79 days later
  10. By year end Classic outsells New Coke and Pepsi

Read the real story the story, via The Coca-Cola Company's own history page

What the rebuild changes

  • Take the blind test. Pick cup M or cup Q on the one-sip promise, then see the reveal: you just voted like 191,000 tasters in Project Kansas.
  • Sip versus can. Behind a one-way mirror, toggle one sip, half a can, and a whole can, and watch the winner change from the sweeter formula to the one people grew up with.
  • The SWOT with an empty box. Strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats are all full. The fifth box, what customers feel, says "Not measured" until you press "What we missed".
  • The test plays out. The recommendation says "watch the hotline"; then the hotline counts from 400 to 1,500 calls a day and the timeline runs 79 days to Classic.

Make yours in ChatGPT

Type your site. We'll write the prompt with Coca-Cola's structure and your brand.